TALKS with a potential operator to run Newton Abbot’s controversial Market Hall after its £5million upgrade have stalled, it has been confirmed.

Teignbridge Council has admitted that it’s ‘not fully satisfied’ the prospective operator would provide a secure long term future for the market.

The council has come in for strong criticism following lengthy delays to reopening the historic market building following the refit with claims it had become a White Elephant.

The reopening had already been delayed until spring next year at the earliest but now that remains highly unlikely.

Independent Teignbridge councillors, led by Cllr Jane Taylor have secured a full discussion about the market for January.

Cllr Taylor said: ‘A market hall without market traders is not a success story, it's a complete delivery failure.’

She said it was ‘time for accountability’ after the project saw £5m spent and still no opening date.

Now, Teignbridge Council has announced it is ‘reviewing options’ for the the future operation of the Market Hall.

A spokesman said: ‘Following extensive discussions, checks and assessments with the prospective operator, the council is currently not currently fully satisfied that the proposed arrangements would provide a secure long-term future for the Market Hall.

'The council has therefore informed the prospective operator that it is reviewing its options to ensure the Market Hall has a sustainable and successful future.

'Discussions with the prospective operator remain ongoing, and the council continues to encourage them to pursue the opportunity.’

But this leaves the council trying to find a way to open the market while ‘securing a sustainable, long-term future for the jewel in Newton Abbot’s crown’.

No final decision has been made about the future operating arrangements, the council said.

It is now waiting for feedback from industry specialists to advise on the best way forward with all options to be considered.

The Grade II listed market building has been closed since October 2024 with some former stallholders operating from the former Post Office.

Residents have already been highly critical of the length of time the project has taken and some traders have moved to other premises.

As part of the new review, the council is considering whether to complete the remaining internal fit-out works itself, ahead of handing over to an operator.

Previously, it had planned to wait until a new operator was in place to help decide how the inside should be fitted out.

Doing the work now would mean the Market Hall is ready for a new operator to move in and open sooner.

This could help prepare the building for occupation while providing greater flexibility over how the Market Hall is used.

But any proposal would still need to go through the appropriate financial and decision-making processes.

Councillor David Palethorpe, Deputy Leader and Executive Member for Economy, Estates and Major Projects, said: ‘We know residents, traders and businesses are eager to see the Market Hall open, and we share their frustration that this has taken longer than expected.

‘The redevelopment has delivered a significant improvement to this important historic building, but completing the construction work was only part of the challenge. We also need to make sure the Market Hall can operate successfully in the long term.

‘We remain committed to making the Market Hall a success.’